shop | mailing lists
musicOMH
Facebook Twitter
music: album reviews
Hope Of The States - Left (Columbia)
UK release date: 19 June 2006
5 stars
Hope Of The States - Left

buy this title


track listing

1. Seconds
2. Blood Meridian
3. Sing It Out
4. Bonfires
5. Good Fight
6. Left
7. Industry
8. This Is A Question
9. Little Silver Birds
10. Four
11. January
12. Forwardirektion
13. Church Choir
Bon Jovi have been a lot of things in their time. Spiritual follicle Godfathers to the Towers Of London, sex symbols for menopausal women, serial daters of those far more attractive than themselves, but one thing has always been constant. Musically, they've always been complete bobbins. But maybe that was never their purpose on this earth. Maybe their place is somewhere else. Maybe their raison d'etre is as soft rock's very own Nostradamus. Because fourscore and ten (ok, three) years after they first suggested it, finally it has come to pass. This Left feels right.

Very, very right. Hope Of The States have waded into battle once more, two years after The Lost Riots, cutting away the chaff and leaving only wheat, standing up, sticking a chin out, and taking the world on.

Taking on, and winning; Left is a monumental, spectacular achievement. Where the debut occasionally bogged down in wide-eyed over indulgence, Left pulsates with intent and purpose, marching its songs in double time to glorious effect.

Industry and Four both seethe in the same restless fashion, spitting vitriol and lobbing three minute hand grenades of razor-edged riffs squarely at the people to blame. The later particular demonstrates the, rather marvellous, new found ability to make twice the point in half the time, as the whole thing cascades down like Bloc Party, Radiohead and Muse being simultaneously thrown down a lift shaft, and Sam Herily's defiant vocals ("You didn't think we could / "You didn't think we would" / "But we did!") grab centre stage, look it in the eye, and knee it squarely in the bollocks.

But the experimentation and the huge orchestral swirls do remain. They haven't lost the nerve, or the ability, to stretch songs out into the widescreen. But by tempering the occasions when they get all Moricone on us with the more concise panzer-attack moments, the effect is so much grander: Little Silver Birds flutters along on delicate plucked wings before unleashing hell with an orchestra the size of the chip on Johnny Borrell's shoulder and FORWARDIREKTION:'s epic good vibes couldn't be more uplifting if they came with underwiring.

But it's probably the album closing The Church Choir which best illustrates what has become of HotS; like Nick Cave ringing the Division Bell in the last remaining cathedral of sound as the ghost of GYBE! is laid to rest.

And if that track sees them bury the over-earnestness, then the opening salvo of Blood Meridian and Sing It Out is the band strafing the road that led them there, the one marked 'possible post rockers' (twinned with being the new Mogwai), with rampant abandon and dead-eyed accuracy.

A truly great record, and also a tremendously hopeful one. HotS have proven they can do big, they've proven they can do clever, and they've proven they can do digestible, but what Left manages is to show the ability to do all of these things at once. Which, at the moment, makes Hope Of The States totally untouchable.

share
end of year feature
musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2009
From the nearly 700 albums we reviewed this year, which did our writers love the most?
Introduction
50-41 | 40-31 | 30-21
20-11 | 10-4 | 1-3



released this week
Gorillaz - Plastic Beach Liars - Sisterworld New Young Pony Club - The Optimist Broken Bells - Broken Bells
Sa Dingding - Harmony Amy Macdonald - A Curious Thing Titus Andronicus - The Monitor The Besnard Lakes - The Besnard Lakes Are The Roaring Night
Gonjasufi - A Sufi And A Killer Two Door Cinema Club - Tourist History Pavement - Quarantine The Past: The Best Of Pavement Kris Drever - Mark The Hard Earth
albums coming soon
Jónsi - Go Laura Marling - I Speak Because I Can She & Him - Volume Two The Radio Dept - Clinging To A Scheme
recent releases
Joanna Newsom - Have One On Me The Knife - Tomorrow, In A Year Archie Bronson Outfit - Coconut Frightened Rabbit - The Winter Of Mixed Drinks
Ellie Goulding - Lights Tunng - ...And Then We Saw Land Thus:Owls - Cardiac Malformations Turin Brakes - Outbursts
Alphabeat - The Beat Is... cliffordandcalix - Lost Foundling Polar Bear - Peepers Hanoi Janes - Year Of Panic
Sambassadeur - European Errors - Come Down With Me Shy Child - Liquid Love Blood Red Shoes - Fire Like This
Efterklang - Magic Chairs Marina & The Diamonds - The Family Jewels Ali Farka Touré & Toumani Diabaté - Ali And Toumani Holly Miranda - The Magician's Private Library
  1. more album reviews

TOP ARTICLES NOW
ALBUMS OUT THIS WEEK: David G Cox, Lou Rhodes, Dan Le Sac vs Scroobius Pip, Christopher Lee, The Automatic, The Moons...

INTERVIEW: Jaga Jazzist talk prog

INTERVIEW: Editors' Tom Smith opens up

FEATURE: Glee: The Music

GIG REVIEWS: Kate Nash, Four Tet, She Keeps Bees, John Cale, Broken Bells, FM Belfast

RELATED ARTICLES
INTERVIEW:
Hope Of The States

ALBUM:
Hope Of The States - Left

TRACK:
Hope Of The States - Left

TRACK:
Hope Of The States - Sing It Out

TRACK:
Hope Of The States - Blood Meridian EP

GIG:
Hope Of The States @ Kings College, London

GIG:
Hope Of The States @ Manchester University

AUDIO:
Hope Of The States - Left

EXTERNAL LINKS
Hope Of The States



  more album reviews...



musicOMH
about us
contact
copyright
home
elsewhere
Twitter
Facebook
Last.fm
Soundcloud
MySpace
© 1999-2010 OMH