So as we hadn't spotted Mr Donohoe beginning to spend some portion of his time on stage cha-cha'ing from front to back, there's no reason to to expect anything other than more of the same from Klang.

Lo and behold, there isn't. Despite all the talk of moving to Berlin, of being sick and tired of the London music scene, it's remarkable how similar this record sounds to ground previously trod by The Rakes. Particularly the bits trod whilst they were fairly major players in what suspiciously looked like a London music scene of two-thousand-and-summit.

The major difference is the stripping of the half-hearted and wholly misjudged attempts to shoehorn the kind of club-footed, cack-handed, post 7/7 social commentary that makes the Daily Express look well judged and even handed, and made their last album (Ten New Messages) so unappealing.

Safer to stick to the kind of treatise that sounds like philosophy after 12 pints. Like their debut. Which, when you think about it - in terms of 19th Century French politicians, and these days that's the only way to consider anything - is a little bit depressing. A bit "there go all my people. I must find out where they are going so I can lead them."

Still, when they tried to lean on the boundaries we rejected them wholesale, so it's not unexpected to find revision rather than revolution at the centre of their third album.

To be fair, on a lot of levels it's a smart move. From beginning to end Klang is pin sharp, ridiculously taut and pithier than Stephen Fry's orange. You're In It bounds in and out of existence in double-quick time, all chopped chords and pulsating basslines; there's a brilliant hook which wraps the chorus of That's The Reason in Strokes-like catchiness and neat little lines and flashes of inspiration abound.

But nothing ever really comes of it. The Loneliness Of The Outdoor Smokers (the Hoxton Square cousin to Elbow's none-more-northern The Loneliness Of A Tower Crane Driver?) could be a smirkingly clever metaphor for noughties sadness and ennui, but the song just elbows past in the same brusque fashion as everything else. Never stopping to consider anything more than the appearance.

It's like a film singularly scripted with the tag lines from the posters. A book constructed solely from the blurbs on the back. It's all surface no feeling. You won't dislike Klang. You may even find yourself grinning at bits of it. But, ultimately, you just won't remember it 15 minutes after it's over.

share:  Facebook | Digg | del.icio.us | more

Mercury Prize 2009 nominees