shop | mailing lists
musicOMH
Facebook Twitter
music: album reviews
Sugababes - Catfights And Spotlights (Island)
UK release date: 20 October 2008
1.5 stars
Sugababes - Catfights And Spotlights

buy this title


track listing

1. Girls
2. You On A Good Day
3. No Can Do
4. Hanging On A Star
5. Side Chick
6. Unbreakable Heart
7. Sunday Rain
8. Every Heart Broken
9. Beware
10. Nothing's As Good As You
11. Sound Of Goodbye
12. Can We Call A Truce
13. About You Now (Acoustic)
14. She's Like A Star ft Taio Cruz
Am I behind the times or has the world gone mad? Here we have a band, who last summer (on account of their musical merit, no doubt) dined with Gordon Brown and Bill Clinton at Nelson Mandela's house. Nelson Mandela! It's a screaming example, as if one were needed, of the sheer power and money-spinning potential of chart-topping, brazen, pretty-girl pop.

By now, unless you've been living under a stone, you've heard the new Sugababes song, the lead single from Catfights And Spotlights, Girls - a cover of Ernie K. Doe's classic Here Come The Girls. Admit it, it's a pop belter - but then Sugababes have pedigree in this department. Freak Like Me, Push The Button - their singles always seem to have pop hooks like talons that slyly pierce their way into you, while Keisha, Heidi, and Amelle smile innocently.

For an album whose alleged goals are to showcase a new Sugababes, one that is unified and over the departure of Mutya Buena, a Sugababes that wish to extol the virtues of the independent woman, Catfights And Spotlights is full of early contradictions. I mean, the title hardly screams unity does it?

And then there's the lyrics to No Can Do, whose gloriously ridiculous lyrics proclaim "You messed up from your chromosomes to your enzymes" and proceed to tell a tale of some feckless bloke, a male gold digger, before the chorus reassures: "but baby I'm sticking with you anyway", is this the independent women we're supposed to believe Sugababes have grown into?

Similarly No Can Do's "I've been thinking about how you've been messing around/Why do you get your kicks from hurting me?" is a pitiful lament that would be more suited to a morose violin than a pro-feminist sensibility. Women's lib must be kicking herself!

The Barbie-doll innocent pop of Hanging On A Star is pathetic, and infuriating. And when you consider what belting singles this trio release, as well as the fact that this is their sixth album it compounds major problems. They're experienced, and should know better.

Side Chick duly administers some dark pop R&B antidote, with a sassy harmonised vocal hook, it screams "Pick me as a single!". Led by Keisha Buchanan, it is demonstrative, as is the entire album, of how much she has personally developed as a vocalist, boasting a genuinely adept vocal talent, with a powerful delivery, and a knowing depth - it's no coincidence that Sugababes' finest moments generally have Keisha at their centre.

Unbreakable has a shit verse rescued by a belting chorus, while Sunday Rain gets caught pondering how different things might have ended up if it was Duffy.

Listen to it for Girls, Side Chick, and Sunday Rain. The other bloated, mind-alteringly infuriating songs are deadweights.

share
end of year feature
musicOMH's Top 50 Albums Of 2009
From the nearly 700 albums we reviewed this year, which did our writers love the most?
Introduction
50-41 | 40-31 | 30-21
20-11 | 10-4 | 1-3



released this week
Laura Marling - I Speak Because I Can Son Of Dave - Shake A Bone Autechre - Oversteps Mary J Blige - Stronger With Each Tear
Robyn Hitchcock & The Venus 3 - Propellor Time Seabear - We Built A Fire Daedelus - Righteous Fists Of Harmony Mixtapes & Cellmates - ROX
albums coming soon
Jónsi - Go Tracey Thorn - Love And Its Opposite She & Him - Volume Two The Radio Dept - Clinging To A Scheme
recent releases
David G Cox - David G Cox Lou Rhodes - One Good Thing Dan Le Sac vs Scroobius Pip - The Logic Of Chance Christopher Lee - Charlemagne: By The Sword And The Cross
Gorillaz - Plastic Beach Liars - Sisterworld New Young Pony Club - The Optimist Broken Bells - Broken Bells
Sa Dingding - Harmony Amy Macdonald - A Curious Thing Titus Andronicus - The Monitor The Besnard Lakes - The Besnard Lakes Are The Roaring Night
Gonjasufi - A Sufi And A Killer Two Door Cinema Club - Tourist History Pavement - Quarantine The Past: The Best Of Pavement Kris Drever - Mark The Hard Earth
Joanna Newsom - Have One On Me The Knife - Tomorrow, In A Year Archie Bronson Outfit - Coconut Frightened Rabbit - The Winter Of Mixed Drinks
Ellie Goulding - Lights Tunng - ...And Then We Saw Land Thus:Owls - Cardiac Malformations Turin Brakes - Outbursts
  1. more album reviews

TOP ARTICLES NOW
ALBUMS OUT THIS WEEK: Laura Marling, Son Of Dave, Autechre, Mary J Blige, Robyn Hitchcock, Seabear, Daedelus, Mixtapes & Cellmates...

FEATURE: Galaxie 500

INTERVIEW: Jaga Jazzist talk prog

FEATURE: Glee: The Music

INTERVIEW: Editors' Tom Smith opens up

RELATED ARTICLES
INTERVIEW:
Sugababes

ALBUM:
Sugababes - Catfights And Spotlights

ALBUM:
Sugababes - Overloaded:The Singles Collection

ALBUM:
Sugababes - Taller In More Ways

GIG:
Sugababes @ City Hall, Sheffield

VIDEO:
Sugababes - Red Dress

VIDEO:
Sugababes - Push The Button

AUDIO:
Sugababes - Taller In More Ways

TRACK:
Sugababes - Easy

TRACK:
Sugababes - Follow Me Home

TRACK:
Sugababes - Red Dress

TRACK:
Sugababes - Push The Button

TRACK:
Sugababes - Caught In A Moment

TRACK:
Sugababes - In The Middle

TRACK:
Sugababes - Too Lost In You

EXTERNAL LINKS
Sugababes



  more album reviews...



musicOMH
about us
contact
copyright
home
elsewhere
Twitter
Facebook
Last.fm
Soundcloud
MySpace
© 1999-2010 OMH